8 min read
Can the World’s Greatest Technology Also Become a Disappointing Investment?
Every major investment bubble begins with a truth.
Railways changed the world. Electricity changed the world. The internet changed the world.
Artificial intelligence will probably do the same.
But here’s the uncomfortable question.
Can you be right about the technology, and still lose money?
History suggests the answer is yes.
Time and again, revolutionary technologies have transformed economies and improved our lives, yet many of the investors who recognised their potential still failed to make money. The technology wasn’t the problem. More often than not, investors simply paid too much and built unrealistic expectations into the price.
That brings us to artificial intelligence.
AI has become the hottest investment theme in the world. Companies are investing hundreds of billions of dollars in data centres, specialised computer chips and increasingly powerful AI models. Share prices have surged, investors have rushed to participate, and many commentators believe AI will transform the global economy.
They may well be right.
The more useful question is whether so much future success has already been built into today’s share prices that expectations have become unrealistic.
History Doesn’t Repeat… But It Often Rhymes
Every generation believes it is witnessing a technology unlike anything that came before. During the 1800s it was canals and railways. In the twentieth century it was electricity and, later, the internet. Each transformed society in ways that were almost impossible to imagine at the time.
The economic benefits were enormous.
So why did so many investors still lose money?
It wasn’t because the technology failed, nor because the future never arrived. In many cases, the technology exceeded expectations. Investors became so enthusiastic that they paid prices assuming years of future success. When those expectations eventually collided with reality, many discovered they had bought a wonderful technology at the wrong price.
History’s Clue
Britain’s railway boom in the 1840s changed the world. Rail transport transformed commerce, connected cities and fuelled economic growth for generations. Investors correctly recognised the opportunity and poured money into railway companies.
Many still lost fortunes.
Not because the railways failed, but because expectations became unrealistic and share prices ran far ahead of business reality. The railways succeeded brilliantly. Many shareholders did not.
Price Matters More Than Promise
That’s a distinction worth remembering. A great technology does not automatically become a great investment. If you remember only one idea from this article, make it this:
History doesn’t punish investors for backing the wrong technology. More often, it punishes them for paying the wrong price.
What Makes AI Different?
The honest answer is that we don’t know yet. That’s precisely why investing can never be about certainty.
There is little doubt that AI has enormous potential. It is already changing the way businesses operate and may well become one of the defining technologies of our generation. Whether that happens, however, is almost beside the point.
A more useful question is whether investors have become so enthusiastic that they’ve already priced years of future success into today’s valuations.
History tells us that every major technological revolution attracted enormous amounts of investment because people believed they had discovered the future. In many respects they were right. The technologies did change the world. Investors often came unstuck by assuming profits would arrive more quickly than they did and that every company would share in the rewards.
Rather than asking, “Will AI change the world?” perhaps the better question is, “How much of that future has already been priced into today’s market?”
Looking Beyond the Headlines
History teaches us another important lesson. Technological leadership doesn’t always belong to the company, or even the country, that spends the most money.
One of the more interesting developments is unfolding in China. According to Stanford University’s AI Index, private AI investment in the United States is dramatically higher than in China. Yet Chinese AI models have rapidly narrowed the performance gap.
It’s far too early to draw firm conclusions. Even so, the trend reminds us that spending significantly more money doesn’t always produce proportionately better results. That’s another force worth watching because it may influence future competition, profitability and investment returns.
Joining the Dots
One of the easiest traps investors fall into is confusing a great business with a great investment. The business may be exceptional, the technology may genuinely change the world and the management team may execute brilliantly. Even so, if expectations become unrealistic and investors pay too much, the investment can still disappoint.
That’s why, at Wealthwise, we don’t begin by trying to predict the future. We begin by asking what forces are shaping the market, how those forces are connected and whether the evidence supports our view. Only then do we turn to the charts to see whether the market agrees with our thinking.
History rarely hands investors the answers. What it does provide are clues. Our job is to recognise those clues, understand how they connect and make informed investment decisions based on evidence rather than excitement.
Wealthwise Principle
Technology creates opportunity. Price determines return.
Sources & Further Reading
This article draws on a range of publicly available research and historical sources. Any opinions expressed are those of the author.
General Advice Warning
This article contains general information only and does not take into account your personal circumstances. Before making financial, tax or legal decisions, seek advice from appropriately qualified professionals.
Stock Market Investor Education:
‘Invest for Success’ – Learn how to bring Risk Management, Value and Timing together within a structured investment framework. The 4-week program begins with an immersive two-day, face-to-face workshop, followed by four weekly one-on-one Application Sessions to help you put what you’ve learned into practice.